Contents

Homemade Cinnamon Vanilla Ice Cream Recipe: Creamy, Spiced Perfection

There’s a distinct charm and undeniable richness that comes from homemade ice cream, and this **Homemade Cinnamon Vanilla Ice Cream** truly embodies that essence. Forget the mundane flavors of store-bought tubs; nothing can quite compare to the vibrant, authentic taste of crafting your own cinnamon and vanilla bean ice cream right in your kitchen. This lightly spiced, incredibly creamy dessert isn’t just a treat on its own; it’s a sublime accompaniment that elevates any autumn pie, crisp, or cake. Imagine a warm apple crisp or a slice of pumpkin pie, perfectly complemented by a scoop of this comforting, spiced delight.

Embracing the Joy of Homemade Ice Cream

The thought of making **homemade ice cream** often conjures images of arduous hand-cranking, rock salt, and endless labor for a small, potentially grainy scoop. Many people are intimidated by the process, perhaps recalling childhood memories of tedious efforts that resulted in an ice cream that was more “cream” than “ice” and barely worth the exertion. Those days, thankfully, are long gone!

With modern, simple-to-use ice cream makers, preparing a batch of rich, velvety ice cream is a straightforward and enjoyable process. These appliances take the hard work out of churning, allowing you to focus on the exciting part: experimenting with specialty flavors like this divine cinnamon vanilla creation. Crafting your own ice cream opens up a world of possibilities, ensuring a fresh, preservative-free dessert with an unparalleled depth of flavor that store-bought options simply cannot match. It’s a culinary experience that’s both rewarding and incredibly delicious, making every scoop a moment to savor.

Incorporating a hint of cinnamon into classic homemade vanilla ice cream is one of my favorite variations, especially as the cooler months approach. The warm, inviting spice instantly evokes the cozy feeling of autumn, making it the perfect topping for cherished fall desserts. Imagine it melting delicately over a warm slice of apple crisp, alongside a tender piece of fresh apple cake, or as a creamy counterpoint to a rich pumpkin cake. The subtle spice adds a layer of sophistication and comfort that enhances these seasonal favorites beautifully.

Finding Your Perfect Cinnamon Balance

Working with cinnamon can sometimes feel like a delicate balancing act. Its intensity can vary significantly, even within the same type, and its potency can diminish over time while stored on your pantry shelf. This is why my suggestion for the amount to use is based on personal preference, and I encourage you to find your own sweet spot.

For this **cinnamon vanilla ice cream**, I prefer a subtle whisper of cinnamon rather than an overpowering burst. I aim for a delicate warmth that complements the vanilla, not a “cinnamon jawbreaker” candy sensation that dominates the palate. However, your taste buds are the ultimate judge! I highly recommend starting with a smaller amount of cinnamon and conducting little taste tests as you mix the ingredients. You can always stir in more ground cinnamon if you desire a bolder flavor, but it’s impossible to remove it once added. Remember, depending on the quantity of cinnamon you incorporate, the final color of your ice cream may also vary slightly, taking on a warmer, spiced hue.

Is Cinnamon Ice Cream the Same as Mexican Ice Cream?

While some individuals informally refer to homemade cinnamon ice cream as “Mexican Ice Cream,” it’s important to understand the nuances. Cinnamon is indeed a beloved and popular spice in Mexican cuisine and is a cherished ice cream flavor throughout Mexico. However, the defining characteristic that often distinguishes a Mexican-style ice cream from a traditional American one isn’t solely the cinnamon, but rather the base’s fat content.

Authentic Mexican ice cream typically contains less fat than its American counterpart, which often relies heavily on rich, thick heavy cream. Instead, Mexican ice cream formulations frequently utilize a blend of milk and cream, resulting in a lighter, sometimes icier, and incredibly refreshing texture. This recipe, while featuring the popular Mexican flavor of cinnamon, leans into a more traditional American-style creaminess, using heavy cream for that indulgent, rich mouthfeel. So, while it captures the spirit of cinnamon-flavored delights, its texture might differ from a true Mexican-style helado.

Key Ingredients for Your Cinnamon Vanilla Ice Cream Adventure

Like many truly exceptional ice cream flavors, everything begins with a classic vanilla ice cream base. This foundational custard provides the perfect canvas upon which to build your desired flavors. Feel free to unleash your creativity; for instance, you could easily swap the cinnamon for homemade pumpkin pie spice to craft another delightful autumn variation. But for this specific recipe, here’s what you’ll need to gather to create your rich and creamy cinnamon vanilla dream:

Whole Milk: The base for our creamy custard, providing essential liquid and contributing to the overall smooth texture.
Heavy Cream: This is where the true richness and velvety mouthfeel of American-style ice cream comes from. Its high fat content ensures a luxurious scoop.
Vanilla Bean Paste: I highly recommend using a high-quality vanilla bean paste, like this one. It offers a deeper, more complex vanilla flavor than extract and adds those beautiful visible vanilla bean specks.
Granulated Sugar: Essential for sweetness and also plays a crucial role in the ice cream’s texture, preventing it from becoming too icy.
Eggs: These are critical for creating a rich, custardy base, contributing to the ice cream’s unparalleled smoothness and body.
Salt: Just a pinch of salt helps to balance the sweetness and truly enhance all the other flavors, making them pop.
Good Quality Cinnamon: This is where you don’t want to skimp. Invest in a good quality ground cinnamon. The difference in flavor is remarkable, and you’ll be glad you did for that authentic, warm spice.

That’s it! When you see the simplicity of these wholesome ingredients, it becomes clear why homemade ice cream vastly surpasses many store-bought varieties. Commercial ice creams often list additives like xanthan gum or other stabilizers. While there’s nothing inherently wrong with xanthan gum in moderation, its purpose in ice cream is often to mimic the smooth texture that real, fresh cream and a proper custard base provide naturally. With homemade, the pure goodness of dairy and natural flavors shines through, delivering an unadulterated, superior experience.

Easy Steps to Making Homemade Cinnamon Ice Cream

Making this delicious ice cream is simpler than you might imagine, especially with an ice cream maker. The key is to thoroughly mix your ingredients to create a smooth base before churning.

Beat Eggs Until Fluffy: Start by beating your eggs until they are light, airy, and fluffy. You can achieve this with a hand whisk or a hand blender. The goal is to incorporate air and create a stable base, similar to preparing a custard. Be careful not to let them get too warm if using an electric mixer to avoid any hint of scrambling.
Gradually Add Sugar: Slowly add the granulated sugar to the fluffy eggs, beating continuously until it’s fully combined and dissolved into the mixture. This step is crucial for both sweetness and ensuring a smooth, non-gritty texture in your final ice cream.
Combine Remaining Ingredients: Once the eggs and sugar are well blended, add in the heavy cream, whole milk, vanilla bean paste, and salt. Mix everything together until fully incorporated. Now is the time to stir in your good quality ground cinnamon. Remember to taste and adjust the cinnamon to your preference before proceeding.
Churn in Your Ice Cream Maker: Pour the prepared mixture into your ice cream maker. Follow the specific instructions that came with your appliance, as churning times can vary. Most machines will churn the mixture into a soft-serve consistency.
Blend Until Frozen: Continue to churn according to your machine’s guidance until the ice cream reaches a thick, soft-serve consistency. It will be deliciously creamy but not yet firm enough for scooping.
Harden in the Freezer: Transfer the soft ice cream into a freezer-safe container. I find that loaf pans work exceptionally well for this, especially when covered tightly with heavy-duty foil or plastic wrap. Place it in the freezer for at least a few hours, or ideally overnight, to allow it to fully harden to a scoopable consistency.

The secret to exceptional homemade ice cream lies in the initial blending. Ensuring the eggs are light and fluffy and that the sugar is completely dissolved into the mixture prevents any graininess and contributes to that desired smooth texture. The salt might seem unusual in a sweet dessert, but it acts as a flavor enhancer, helping to brighten and balance the rich sweetness of the cream and sugar. This simple process yields an incomparably fresh and flavorful dessert that you’ll be proud to share!

Your rich and creamy **Cinnamon Vanilla Ice Cream** — freshly blended in the ice cream maker and now ready for the freezer, awaiting its transformation into a firm, scoopable delight.

I find freezing it in loaf pans covered in heavy duty foil works exceptionally well for even hardening and easy storage.

Love it? Pin It!

Don’t forget where you found this incredible recipe! Pin it to your favorite Pinterest recipe board now so you can easily find it later when that ice cream craving strikes!

Looking for more inspiration? Try Vanilla Caramel Swirl Ice Cream!

Creative Flavor Pairings & Variations for Cinnamon Ice Cream

The beauty of a vanilla ice cream base is its incredible versatility, allowing you to venture in countless flavorful directions. Adding cinnamon to that base only broadens the horizon, as cinnamon harmonizes beautifully with many of the same ingredients that complement vanilla. Don’t hesitate to get creative with your mix-ins and swirls!

Consider adding mini chocolate chips for a spiced chocolate chip ice cream, or dried banana bits for a delightful banana-cinnamon fusion. A swirl of caramel or butterscotch sauce would also meld perfectly with the warm spice notes. For a fruity twist, even a spoonful of strawberry preserves or a ripple of apple butter mixed in would work quite nicely, creating a complex and comforting flavor profile. Think about toasted nuts like pecans or walnuts for added texture and a nutty depth. The possibilities are truly endless when you have such a versatile and delicious base like cinnamon vanilla ice cream!

More Irresistible Ice Cream Desserts to Explore

Ice cream holds a special, cherished place at any dessert table, always promising a delightful end to a meal. If you’re passionate about frozen treats, especially those perfect for fall, here are some other fantastic ice cream recipes to tempt your taste buds:

Spider Web Ice Cream Pie
Grapenut Ice Cream (as pictured above, a unique and delightful Jamaican treat)
Lemon Ice Cream
Grasshopper Pie Ice Cream
Snow Ice Cream
Pineapple Dole Whip

Ready to churn up some cinnamon-spiced magic? Let’s make some ice cream!

Homemade Cinnamon Vanilla Ice Cream in bowl with cinnamon sticks

LIKE THIS RECIPE?
Don’t forget to give it a ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ star rating and
leave a comment below the recipe!

Print Recipe

Homemade Cinnamon Vanilla Ice Cream

Rich and creamy homemade cinnamon vanilla ice cream. No store-bought ice cream can top the flavor of making your own cinnamon and vanilla bean ice cream from scratch!

Prep Time
10 mins

Cook Time
30 mins

Total Time
40 mins

Cuisine:
American

Keyword:
churned, Cinnamon, Cinnamon vanilla ice cream, homemade, no cook, vanilla bean, with cream, with eggs, with ice cream maker

Servings:
1 gallon

Calories:
392kcal

Author:
Michaela Kenkel

Equipment

Taylor & Colledge Organic Vanilla Bean Paste with Seeds, 1.7oz Tube
Kitchenaid Stand Mixer
KitchenAid Hand Mixer
Hamilton Beach 68330N Automatic Ice Cream Maker, 4 Quart, White
Cuisinart ICE-30BC Pure Indulgence 2-Quart Automatic Ice Cream Maker
Ice Cream Scoop with Comfortable Handle

Ingredients

4 eggs
2 1/2 cups sugar
4 cups heavy cream
2 Tablespoons vanilla bean paste
1/2 teaspoon salt
6 cups whole milk
3 teaspoons ground cinnamon

Instructions

Beat eggs until fluffy.
Add sugar a little at a time until combined.
Add in the rest of the ingredients, mix. Stir in ground cinnamon.
Pour into your ice cream maker, follow the instructions that came with it.
Blend until frozen.
Put in the freezer for a few hours to harden. I like to use loaf pans and cover them with foil.

Notes

If you want your ice cream a little “spicier” feel free to adjust the amount of cinnamon in the recipe. Begin by stirring in 1 teaspoonful at a time until your desired flavor is achieved. Do this before freezing.

Nutrition